Filtering
Week: Week 35 ×
Attack target: Rule of Law ×
Trait: Judicial independence is eroded through politicized appointments ×
Clear all
☆ Save this search
Tier 1 carried by a primary record
Corroborated 2+ independent news desks
Every result is verified and democracy-related.
Open an event to see its evidence. Attack and trait tags link to their definitions
Sep 19, 2025 Judge Steven Merryday dismissed Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit against the New York Times Tier 1 · Primary Institutions and Governance
A federal court rejected a presidential lawsuit as improper, protecting press freedom from litigation intimidation.
Independently corroborated by5 independent news desks
Associated Press · Axios · CNBC · PBS · The Guardian
Supporting reportingSurfacings — do not carry alone
Supporting reports
- Judge Merryday dismissed Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit against the New York Times — U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday, appointed by President George H.W. Bush, threw out the defamation complaint filed by President Trump on September 15 against the New York Times. The judge called the complaint "decidedly improper and impermissible" and criticized Trump's legal team for using the lawsuit as a public forum for abusive language. The complaint contained eighty pages of praise for Trump and allegations against the Times before two defamation counts. Merryday imposed a forty-page limit on any amended complaint.
- Federal judge dismisses Trump's $15 billion libel lawsuit against New York Times — US District Judge Steven Merryday in Florida dismissed President Trump's $15 billion libel and defamation lawsuit against the New York Times, ruling that the complaint lacked "any legitimate legal claims." Merryday, a Bush appointee, gave Trump 28 days to file a revised complaint and ridiculed the original filing, stating that a complaint is not "a public forum for vituperation and invective" or "a megaphone for public relations."
- Federal judge tossed Trump's defamation lawsuit against New York Times — A federal judge dismissed Trump's defamation lawsuit against the New York Times, calling the complaint "improper and impermissible" and stating that "a complaint is not a public forum for vituperation and invective — not a protected platform to rage against an adversary." The judge ordered any revised complaint be limited to 40 pages.
Attacks
Verified: Tier 1 primary record
Week 35 – 2025-09-13–2025-09-19
wk35_IG_042
Sep 16, 2025 US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit declined to allow Trump's removal of Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook Tier 1 · Primary Institutions and Governance
The appellate ruling preserved Federal Reserve independence by blocking a politically motivated removal attempt.
Independently corroborated by6 independent news desks
Supporting reportingSurfacings — do not carry alone
Supporting reports
- US appeals court blocks Trump's removal of Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook — The US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit declined to allow President Trump to remove Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook, upholding a lower court's temporary block. Trump had claimed Cook committed mortgage fraud before taking office; Cook denies the allegations and argues they are pretextual retaliation for her monetary policy stance. The 2-1 decision (Biden appointees Garcia and Childs in majority; Trump appointee Katsas dissenting) preserves Cook's seat ahead of a Fed policy meeting. The administration signaled intent to appeal to the Supreme Court.
Verified: Tier 1 primary record
Week 35 – 2025-09-13–2025-09-19
wk35_IG_020
Sep 15, 2025 SCOTUS allowed firing of FTC Commissioner Slaughter to proceed pending appeal Corroborated Institutions and Governance
The Court permitted removal of an independent agency official before final adjudication, drawing dissents over presidential removal power.
Independently corroborated by2 independent news desks
Supporting reportingSurfacings — do not carry alone
Supporting reports
- Supreme Court allows Slaughter firing to proceed pending appeal — The US Supreme Court issued an order allowing Trump's firing of FTC Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter to take effect while the Court agreed to hear full arguments on the merits of the case. The order drew dissents from the three liberal justices, signaling deep disagreement over presidential removal power and independent agency protections.
Attacks
Verified: Corroborated — 2+ independent news desks
Week 35 – 2025-09-13–2025-09-19
wk35_IG_013